I have a problem.
I’m Italian.
Not that there is anything wrong with being Italian. I’m rather proud of my pasta proficiency and having people think that I’m somehow connected to the mob.
There is a downside to this for Italian members of the Church. Specifically, the tie.
Like many Italians, I have no hint of a neck. My head rests directly on my shoulders, with just one vertebrae allowing me to look from side to side. My neck is actually half the size of my waist, and I am not a skinny man. Because of this, the standard Church dress code presents some problems for me. Buttoning the top button of a dress shirt for me is unique challenge as compared to those long-necked guys in Utah. I have to button the *$%! thing almost around one of my cascade of chins, which requires contortions that a 57-year-old man can no longer perform. Forcing a tie on top of that means that I won’t be “thinking Celestial” during Church services. I will be “thinking asphyxia.”
There is some hope, however. The new For the Strength of Youth booklet (too long for a pamphlet and too short for a manual), revises the dress code for youth to, well, no real code. Youth are expected to dress in a way that helps them to feel the Spirit and draw closer to Christ. I expect that the same is true for adults, and there is a lot of wiggle room there.
Does that mean no ties? Maybe so, but my wife won’t let me get away with it. Still, I certainly would prefer that people not ask me, “Brother Ghio, why is your face blue?” I would also like to take the Sacrament without choking.
My wife has suggested that I wear a tie but not close the top button. That feels like cheating, and it makes me look like an exhausted real estate agent. I’ve tried button extenders, but they cut my throat and tend to snap and fly into the next pew. Yelling “incoming” apparently is not considered reverent by some people.
Over the years I’ve seen more casual wear making an appearance. The winter sweater than conceals whether you are wearing a tie. The occasional polo shirt, which gets sour looks that say, “We don’t play polo here, whoremonger.” (They don’t actually include that last bit, but it is my favorite word in the scriptures). I guess that polos are better than a Black Sabbath t-shirt with a Budweiser cap, but not by much.
I don’t see myself winning this fight.
The sisters have a little more wiggle room in their attire, despite being strongly encouraged to wear skirts or dresses instead of pants, a standard that made sense when Lorenzo Snow was tucking his beard into his trousers, but not so much today. Still, women get to wear denim skirts (denim jeans will get you the stink eye, brethren), and they can pair their skirts with T-shirts. So, yeah, there is a double standard, but it cuts both ways.
On a more serious note, I had exactly one baptism on my mission, which was exactly the average for missionaries serving in 1980s Chicago. The one lady I baptized was a wonderful older woman living near the Southside. She was very humble, both in spirit and means. The ward was full of great people, but it was also considerably affluent. The first time she came to services, she was wearing mismatched blouse and pants, both of which likely came from Goodwill. I was so thrilled to have here there that I didn’t even think about the fashion faux pas, but I can’t say that for everybody.
After the block of meetings concluded, the Relief Society President approached this new sister and informed her that she couldn’t be coming to church dressed like that. Those clothes being the best she had, this new member did as she was told: She never came to church again.
We get uptight about the strangest things in the Church, and sometimes we are inexplicably vocal about it. I know that we talk a lot about how members shouldn’t be offended by comments from other members, and there is some truth to that. But there is also something to be said for not saying offensive things. How visitors or our fellow members dress is, and always has been, none of anyone else’s business. If we are tempted to say something about it, we should stop, say a quick prayer, and gently remind ourselves to shut our traps. Not necessarily in that order.
In the meantime, I will bow to peer pressure and wrestle to get that top button done.